Guernsey Crest Ice Cream Co

Chad Jones 2 months ago

Really great spot! Awesome service, tons of selection, and some flavors I didn't expect. It's in this cool historic building that used to be a stable and carriage house and is off the beaten path making parking easier than you would expect in this town. The owner was super nice and walked me through all the seasonal flavors they've got coming for fall and Christmas. I was also pleasantly surprised to see they make a Grape-Nuts ice cream (yes, the cereal!) that's apparently been a longtime favorite. Staff was friendly and polite the whole time. Definitely worth a stop.

Miesha 2 months ago

Been coming here since I was a little girl, the flavor never disappoints. My favs are cherry vanilla and pistachio. I used to get milkshakes until all the young people started working here, they don't know how to make a old thick milkshake, so now I just get the cups or quarts, I'll make my milkshake. And that is the reason I deducted a star!

Mya McGlashan 3 months ago

I’ve been coming here since I was a kid, and it has always been great! The ice cream and service are consistently amazing. Special shoutout to Dom for always going the extra mile. He’s truly one of the best employees I’ve ever had the pleasure of interacting with!

freddy E 5 months ago

Let me tell you about Guernsey ice cream or how we used to call them. The barbudos.. the bearded. The gem of paterson best home crafted ice cream,I use to go there when I wass little and keep goi g now with my childrens. I do recommend 100% its not other place better than that store.

J B 5 months ago

My family has been going to this place for years! Unfortunately, the service has taken a turn for the worse. Recently, one of the staff members treated my aunt very poorly; she asked for her order number, and the guy practically threw the bag onto the pickup counter and didn't say a word to her. They just moved him away from that station, and it was painfully obvious that the young people working there were making fun of her! Today, I went in for three Banana Boats! We order them all the time—always (without banana, but with strawberries, pineapple, and coconut and strawberry ice cream flavors). *Always!* For years! Since I placed my order in Spanish, they must have assumed I didn't understand a word of what they were saying! After I paid—because, mind you, I wasn't asking for anything for free!—the guy said to his coworker (mockingly), "Oh, you're going to *love* these tickets." The coworker then acted as if he is bothered to make the order. Then another guy came over—I think he's one of the owners (the younger one; he was wearing a white polo shirt at the time)—and said, "What? Three Banana Boats? Thank goodness it wasn't four!" ...Excuse me? I am *paying* for this! I repeat: I d